Mood:
Well THAT was a difficult week. Perhaps not "disastrous" as the Canadian Press would have you believe (like they tried to have you believe that the Liberals are the "natural governing party of Canada"), but not quite what we had hoped for.
A few thoughts:
On David Emerson: I am a bit torn on this one. On the one hand, it is fun to poke a stick into the eye of the Liberal party, and getting defectors from the opposition is usually fun sport. On the other hand, the overall optics of the situation leave a little to be desired. A coup is great when it's news today and history tomorrow. If it continues to be news day after day, then it starts to mutate into a fiasco. We can only hope that this dies down soon. For what it's worth, I don't have much of a problem with the whole thing, knowing what I know about political realities. Put it this way, I feel a whole lot better about this one than the Belinda thing. At least this guy had experience in the job.
On the Fortier front, I really don't have much of a problem with it, except for optics. Again, facing a hostile media with such situations is trying at best. Let's see what kind of job he does.
And then there's Garth.
Garth, I'm sure you don't read this blog. I don't normally read yours so I guess we're even. But let me make the following comments and suggestions:
You are a member of the Conservative Party of Canada. Now I know that you have been with the PC party previously, and that you are a former cabinet minister in the honestly awful Campbell administration. I also know that you have learned little about party discipline. Let me explain. It is OK to disagree with some of the policies and decisions of the party. Even I don't agree with everything (let the gays marry for God's sake) and I am free to post whatever I feel like. But I am not a caucus member. Any disagreements that you have with party policy or direction belongs in caucus meetings. It does not under any circumstances belong in a public forum. Further, speculating that your dissent will result in punishment being applied is presumptuous and childish, and constitutes a backhand slap at the Prime Minister. Politics are what they are. Optics are everything. I would think that by now you'd know this. Certainly, if you would like to publicly trash the integrity of the PMO and the party, and members of cabinet, then please feel free to resign from the party and sit as an independent. Then you can speak your mind... if anyone would listen.
Posted by evilcynic
at 11:21 PM EST